Economic Presence
  • Home
  • Paradox found
    • Paradox found

Situational dependence and Dragons

8/30/2011

0 Comments

 
The children’s fairy tale “There’s No Such Thing as a  Dragon” tells the story of a boy who wakes up one morning to find a dragon in his room. The boy’s parents dismiss his attempts to identify the dragon and assure  him that dragons do not exist. Eventually the dragon grows so big that he takes  away their house-it is only then that the parents recognize the dragon - and it  diminishes. In the United States, the political energy has been expended on a manufactured debt  crisis while ignoring the substantive problems in the housing market and household deleveraging that has created a demand shortfall. Those preaching austerity are behaving akin to recommending that a heart attack survivor run 6 miles while he is still in the ICU. They are promoting the right policy at the wrong time. 

From US News & World Report:
"The Fed is running out of options however, as Bernanke himself implicitly acknowledged in his recent Jackson Hole speech. "Most of  the economic policies that  support robust economic growth in the long run are outside the province of the  central bank," he reminded a worldwide audience. 
Bernanke also emphasized that the imperatives of short-term stimulus and  long-term fiscal discipline “are not incompatible.” "

Whether congress will take heed of this inuendo and pass a stimulus package is very much in doubt.
 
What’s more after having watched Japan struggle for more than a decade after their real estate driven financial crisis it is curious that respectable Economists are arguing against government stimulus at this time. 
 
Chicago’s John Cochrane (2009): 
“First,  if money is not going to be printed, it has to come from somewhere. If the government borrows a dollar from you, that is a dollar that you do not spend, or that you do not lend to a company to spend on new investment. Every dollar of increased government spending must correspond to one less dollar of private spending. Jobs created by stimulus spending are offset by jobs lost from the decline in private spending. We can build roads instead of factories, but fiscal stimulus can’t help us to build more of both. This is just accounting, and does not need a complex argument about “crowding out.”

 Really?  Really, with official unemployment above 9.0%? It is fair to argue about the composition and efficacy of stimulus and that not all stimulus is equally expansive; but to say it is not needed after having recently witnessed Japan’s struggle is indefensible.  

Monetary policy cannot solve all problems; we have to rely on the wisdom of Keynes  to get us through this moment. Moreover those that say block grants to states are ineffective because they create no new jobs are missing the point - they preserve existing jobs. To get a terrifying view of the implications of state budget crises watch Bill Gates presentation on TED. Punchline: in order to balance state funding going forward education funding will have to be cut by 50%. Only one state in the union does not have a balanced budget amendment. When Argentina went through difficult financial times one province shut the public school system for a year. Is that where the US is heading? And what does this say about its ability to compete in the future?

Finally, Richard Koo does a great job of highlighting, on slide 36, why Cochrane's crowding out senario would be appropriate if this were a conventional post recession recovery - not one prompted by an asset bubble. In the current situation, monetary policy is ineffective, argues Koo, and fiscal stimulus is appropriate.

 In economics, as in scripture, as in life, dragons exist - the appropriate way to kill them depends on the situation.  

0 Comments

It is going to be a tough decade for the global economy and the BRICS will not save us.

8/29/2011

0 Comments

 
Unfortunately, I agree with much of the sentiments of Michael Pettis and have been teaching them in my International Macro classes (in the case of the Euro) for the past decade. For various reasons, I continue to prefer Brazil out of the BRICS and believe things will be substantively better for them than for the others.  Other than that, my views pretty much line up with Pettis.

Those wanting just a summary click here.
Those wanting more in Pettis own words click here. 

As I pointed out in my last blog, there are millions of jobs that have been lost in manufacturing since China joined the WTO. Absent intervention, these jobs are gone forever, and with the loss of millions of construction jobs, unemployment for the low skilled will become chronic.

I have suggested that that this will lead to a level of social unrest not seen in Amercia since the 60s. Pettis believes that both the US and UK  will become trade protectionist. I see this as the easiest and most likely way that policy makers will deal with problems of social inequality. Fundamental reform of education is much tougher, especially in a budget constrained enviroment.
0 Comments

US Economy in pictures -why we need a stimulus

8/28/2011

0 Comments

 
Picture
 









       

                 First, the good news - real GDP and nominal personal consumption are approaching pre-recession levels. However growth appears to be decelerating.

Picture
                      The bad news is that unemployment is still high - 16% by the broadest measure.

Picture
        The duration of unemployment has more than doubled to 40 weeks.

Picture
           The level of education makes a big difference. Those with bachelor degrees or better have a 4% unemployment rate, while those without a high school diploma have 15% unemployment rate.

Picture
                    Total household debt remains extremely high by historical standards.

Picture
                   Consumer credit has also only fallen marginally.

Picture
                  The employment situation is actually worse because millions have dropped out of the work force.

Picture
                  Corporate profits have grown through the last decade and recovered sharply. In Sept. 2001, China was allowed membership in the WTO and the transfer of low skill manufacturing jobs out of Amercia began in earnest and has continued ever since.

Picture
                        The loss of manufacturing coincided with China's entry in the WTO and the rise in corporate profits. Has it hit a bottom? 

Picture
                                            Close to 7 million jobs lost since last recession.

Picture
                                       Construction employment also hard hit and not bouncing back.

Picture
                              Warren Buffet, on latest Charlie Rose appearance, says the economy will get back to normal once housing starts get back to one million. Seems like we have not yet turned a corner in that direction.

Picture
                                The Federal Reserve has applied monetray policy very aggressively and yet the economy is in a stall. Only fiscal is left. As Nouriel Robini points out ,in a recent Charlie Rose appearence, that when millions of construction workers are unemployed now is the time to rebuild the roads and bridges of Amercia.  

0 Comments

I Predict A Riot

8/22/2011

0 Comments

 
Social unrest is on the rise the world over. From the “Arab spring” to the London riots to the Tea Party protests in the US to the Chinese outrage over the high speed rail derailment to protests over reforms in Greece. The global economy has been in a recession, and currently, the major economies of the world are pursing austerity measures. New research finds a link between contractionary government policies in Europe over the last 90 years and civil unrest.  60 minutes recently did a piece stating that child poverty may soon reach 25% in America. 

According to the World Bank, food prices are up 33%, year over year, in July. Some have pointed out that this is the only major accomplishment of Quantitative Easing.  Low skilled labour is down, as manufacturing has been moved to developing countries
and because the construction industry, decimated by the housing bubble, has no sign of recovering any time soon. Thus, the consequences of the global financial crisis are falling disproportionately on the poor and middle class. 
 
The Atlantic has an excellent piece on this topic, for their September issue, titled ’Can the Middle Class Be Saved?’. Hardly a progressive extremist, Warren Buffet recently wrote an article for the NY Times, ‘Stop Coddling the  Super-Rich’. He  followed the article up with an interview on Charlie Rose. Warren explained that his last year’s “all –in” tax rate at 17%, on over 60 million in earnings, was approximately half the average rate paid by those working in his office. So much for the notion of shared sacrifice.
 
My point is simple. The poor and the middle class are being disenfranchised in the developed world. The London Riots should be a warning to American policy makers. If you don’t start designing polices,  like a fiscal stimulus, that will get the poor working again your system will become destabilized and may implode. For those who say it can’t happen here because of American exceptionalism, I say it’s already happening. Sarah Palin, when pushed, couldn’t recount Paul Revere’s historic warnings. Let's hope she and her Tea Party friends can heed contemporaneous political warnings. There is a new British invasion underway, and  it doesn’t involve cute guys with mop tops.

American policy makers have been warned, take a lesson from Brazil. Otherwise expect violent unrest,  kidnapping and flash mobs.

As the Kaiser Chiefs warned:

Watching the people get lairy
Is not very pretty I tell thee
Walking  through town is quite scary
And not very sensible either

A friend of a friend he got beaten
He looked the wrong way at a policeman
Would never have happened to Smeaton
An old Leodensian

La-ah-ah, lalala la la  la
Ah-ah-ah, lalala la la la

I predict a riot, I predict a riot
I predict a riot, I predict a riot

I tried to get to my taxi
A man in a  tracksuit attacked me
He said that he saw it before me
Wants to get  things  a bit gory

Girls scrabble around with no clothes on
To borrow  a pound  for a condom
If it wasn't for chip fat, they'd be frozen
They're not very  sensible

La-ah-ah, lalala la la la
Ah-ah-ah, lalala la la la

I predict a riot, I predict a riot
I predict a riot, I predict a  riot

And if there's anybody left in here
That doesn't want to be out there 
0 Comments

RESOLVED - a debate movie prompts reflections on society

8/20/2011

0 Comments

 
My son with his debating partner won the provincial championships in debating last year. I was one of five judges for the provincial final in the  age class above him. 

Last night we watched the documentary “Resolved”. We were surprised to see that the prominent debating style in the US had morphed into something much different than the way we debate in Canada.  The  US debating style is dominated by participant’s speed talking at about 400 words a minute. A ton of research is conducted to support this epic level of verbal spew. In contrast, the Canadian debating system seems to be built more  on three pillar arguments, rhetoric, and the ability to destroy an opponent’s positions in cross examination. In the Canadian debate system, impromptu debates, where the participants have only 15 minutes to prepare, are held in highest regard and viewed as the more significant demonstration of debating prowess. It demonstrates an ability  to think on your feet and articulate those thoughts. It seems like the US system emphasizes quantity while the Canadian system emphasizes quality.  

Of course, learning to do research is a great skill to acquire and as someone whose career has been as a researcher and analyst I value it.  But it strikes me that the American debting system overemphasizes research while underemphasizing  filtering, critical thinking and persuasiveness. In the end, young people need to be taught to think independently, make decisions under time constraints, under uncertainty and defend their positions. 
 
Even my own profession, Economics, suffers from not enough thinkers and too many analysts who can just run time series regressions. The  credit markets froze up in 2008; the financial system flat lined and required open heart resuscitation.  And yet
it appears that most of the mainstream economists and policy makers are treating 2008 like a run of the mill case of the flu or recession. This over optimism is evidenced by the tsunami of market forecasters cutting their growth forecasts.   

These analysts are adept at research, at using econometric programs, and manipulating data. They are not great at thinking. Thinking requires presence, a quality that is being discouraged with the proliferation of cell phone texting and continous connectivity that is endemic. This past week, I saw two people texting while crossing the crosswalk on the TransCanada, in the heart of Calgary. The average teen sends 3000 text messages a month. That’s our future folks.

Unfortunately, the problems confronting the world are going to require people who can think, and the experts in government and finance have shown us they are not good at that skill. We have outsourced out thinking to experts in society. They have failed us and will continue to do so. We need to assume more responsibility for ourselves and begin to debate the important issues of our day as educated generalists. Otherwise we are doomed. Liz Coleman, in a TED talk, laments this move away from educated generalists to experts. The benefits of specialization, to individuals and nations are a fundamental tenet of economics. From my
perspective, individuals and society need to practice all things in moderation, including moderation. The same goes for specialization.  



0 Comments

Inaugural Post - Irving Fisher - The more things change the more they stay the same.

8/19/2011

0 Comments

 
As it turns out  for my first post I am going to highlight the writings of Irving Fisher “The Purchasing Power of Money” published in 1911 -  the year my father was born. This one is for you Reinhold.

Robert J Shiller recently published a short paper discussing Fisher’s work titled ‘Irving Fisher, Debt Deflation and Crises’ http://cowles.econ.yale.edu/P/cd/d18a/d1817.pdf  (hat tip:Professor Serletis)

Shiller’s behavioural ideas about contracting in terms of baskets rather that individual currencies are interesting but I am struck by how much the Fisher quotes still ring true today. Consider them in the context of the credit binge, the popping of the housing bubble and where investor psychology is today.

 “The  public psychology of going into debt for gain passes through several more or less distinct phases: (a) the lure of big prospective dividends or gains in income in the remote future; (b) the hope of selling at a profit, and realizing a capital gain in the immediate future; (c) the vogue of reckless promotions, taking advantage of the habituation of the public to great expectations; (d) the development of downright fraud, imposing on a public which had grown credulous and gullible.”

 Fisher also talks about the aftermath of a debt bubble and the problem a society has extracting itself from the consequences that follow. 

“Each dollar of debt still unpaid becomes a bigger dollar, and if the over-indebtedness with which we started was great enough, the liquidation of debts cannot keep up with the fall of prices which it causes. In that case, the liquidation defeats itself. While it diminishes the number of dollars owed, it may not do so as fast, as it increases the value of each dollar owed. Then, the very effort of individuals to lessen their burden of debts increases it, because of the mass effect of the stampede to liquidate in swelling each dollar owed.”


0 Comments

First Post!

8/19/2011

0 Comments

 
Start blogging by creating a new post. You can edit or delete me by clicking under the comments. You can also customize your sidebar by dragging in elements from the top bar.
0 Comments

    Author

    Karl Pinno

    Categories

    All
    60 Minutes
    Abnormal Returns
    Academic Publishing
    Advice For Econ Students
    Age
    Aid
    Algo Trading
    Aluminum
    Argentina
    Assortive Matching
    Austerity
    Bank Of England
    Behavioural Economics
    Bio Weapons
    Bis
    Bloomberg
    Bonds
    Bono
    Book Of Mormon
    Brain
    Brazil
    Brics
    Bridgewater Associates
    Buffet
    Calgary
    Canada
    Capital Flight
    Carola Binder
    Cds
    Central Banks
    Chainmail Bikinis
    Chanos
    Child Rearing
    China
    Chris Martenson
    Christmas Wishlist
    Climate Change
    College Humor
    Commercial Banks
    Commodities
    Community
    Computer Programming
    Confirmation Bias
    Conservatism
    Conservative
    Constructive Ambiquity
    Consumer Confidence
    Copper
    Corporate Lending
    Counterparty Risk
    Creativity
    Credit
    Culture
    Cwb
    David Einhorn
    David Rosenberg
    Debate
    Debt Crisis
    Deflation
    Demographics
    Depression
    Development
    Dragons
    Dr. Ed's Blog
    Econ Blogs
    Economics
    Ecri
    Education
    Electricity
    Eurasia Group
    Eurozone
    Excercise
    Externalities
    Falkenblog
    Ferguson
    Fertility
    Filtering
    Financial Crisis 2008
    Financial Engineering
    Financial Reform
    Financial Repression
    Financial Research
    Fiscal Policy
    Fiscal Stimulus
    Fisher
    Fixed Income
    Flood
    Food Prices
    Frank And Cook
    Fraud
    Freidman
    Ft
    Game Theory
    Gender
    Generalist
    George Soros
    Get Smart
    Giffen Good
    Global Banking
    Global Economy
    Gmo
    Godfather
    Gold
    Goldman Sachs
    Great Careers
    Greece
    Greenlight Capital
    Happiness
    Hayman Capital Management Lp
    Hbo
    Health
    Hedge Funds
    Homosexuality
    Housing Market
    Hubbard
    Hugh Hendry
    Hussman
    Ian Bremmer
    Imf
    Inception
    Income Smoothing
    India
    Inequality
    Inflation
    Inflationary Expectations
    Inside Job
    Interest Rates
    Interfluidity
    Intuition
    Inventories
    Iran
    Iraq
    Italy
    Janusian Thinking
    Japan
    Jordan Peterson
    Jp Morgan
    Judgement
    Kalecki Equation
    Krugman
    Kyle Bass
    Larry Smith
    Larry Summers
    Lehman Brothers
    Levitt
    Liberal
    Lonely Island
    Luck
    Macro
    Macro Intro
    Macro Predictions
    Management Consulting
    Marginal Revolution
    Market Design
    Market Monetarism
    Marx
    Matt Taibbi
    Mercantilism
    Michael Portillo
    Milton Friedman
    Mircea Eliade
    Mish
    Mishkin
    Monetary Policy
    Monetary Stimulus
    Multipliers
    Mundell
    Music
    Nanex
    Nfl
    Noahpinion
    Nobel Price In Economics
    Oil Price Volatility
    Oil Production
    Omitted Variable Bias
    Optimism Bias
    Overcomingbias
    Palantir
    Pettis
    Phillips Curve
    Placebo
    Podcasts
    Poker
    Poland
    Politico
    Politics
    Populism
    Portfolio Management
    Positivism
    Prisoner's Dilemma
    Productivity
    Psychology
    Publishing
    Quality
    Quantitative Easing
    Race
    Rand Paul
    Ray Dalio
    Rbc Theory
    Real Interest Rates
    Reality Tv
    Recession
    Redistributionist Reform
    Regulators
    Regulatory Capture
    Remembrance Day
    Research
    Richard Wilkinson
    Riots
    Risk
    Risk Taking
    Robots
    Roubini
    Russia
    Ryan
    Sachs
    Salt
    Saudi Arabia
    Sec
    Seth Klarman
    Shadowbanking
    Shiller
    Signaling
    Smes
    Snap
    Social Policy
    Social Unrest
    Society
    Sorkin
    Soros
    S&P
    Spain
    Specialization
    Speculation
    State Sponsored Terrorism
    Status
    Steve Jobs
    Steven Keen
    Stress
    Structural Unemployment
    Structure Finance
    Sugar
    Suicide
    Svars
    Systemic Risk
    Tax
    Taylor Rule
    Technology
    Ted
    Television
    The Clash
    The Economist
    The Wire
    Thinking
    Thoureau
    Trade
    Trilemma
    Turkey
    Tyler Cowen
    U2
    Unemployment
    Us 2012 Election
    Us Economy
    Us Foreign Policy
    Velocity
    Volatility
    Welfare
    Williams
    Words
    Work
    Writing
    Zerohedge
    Zig Ziglar

    Archives

    November 2017
    October 2017
    March 2017
    January 2017
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    February 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012
    June 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012
    January 2012
    December 2011
    November 2011
    October 2011
    September 2011
    August 2011

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.