Economic Presence
  • Home
  • Paradox found
    • Paradox found

Jeffrey Sachs identifies where he disagrees with Keynesians

4/13/2013

0 Comments

 
Huffington Post.  I agreee with Sachs.

"So, to summarize, what is crude Keynesianism?

(1) The belief in large, stable, and predictable multipliers on taxes and  transfers;
(2) The belief that our problems are due overwhelmingly to a deficiency of aggregate demand, rather than to structural problems that need a long-term approach;
(3) The belief that a rapidly rising debt-GDP ratio is largely benign because interest rates are low today and will stay so
indefinitely;
(4) The belief that "to a large effect, spending is spending," thereby catering to waste and vested interests while ignoring America's urgent investment needs.

That subtler set of policies should include:
(1) Decade-long public investment programs in renewable energy, upgraded public infrastructure, fast rail, job training and the like;
(2) Adequate fiscal revenues (including tolls on infrastructure) to pay for these investments over the course of a decade, including a downward path of the debt-GDP  ratio;
(3) Increased revenues through taxation on high net worth, financial  transactions, high incomes, capital gains and carried interest, offshore  corporate earnings, and carbon emissions, and a stiff crackdown on tax havens  and phony transfer pricing"



0 Comments

New Research Supports the Idea that Foreign Aid Helps Economic Growth

9/25/2012

0 Comments

 
Vox presents research that goes against mainstream economic thinking. Aid actually helps economic growth. Chalk one up for Bono and Jeffrey Sachs. I am particularly annoyed with Dambisa Moyo, anti-aid economist, who I also disagree with on the issue of commodities. 

The Serletis - Barro text that I am teaching (intermediate macro) takes the perspective that trade is ineffective at raising growth -which is mainstream thinking on the topic. Barro even mentions his face to face conversations with Bono re:Debt Jubilee 2000 and his other initiatives. He views Bono as sincere but misguided.
 
Bono was calling for help to be accompanied my meaningful reforms which it strikes me is the standard IMF bailout rationale and the rationale used to  support transfers to the periphery in the Eurozone.
 
I would almost bet that most economists in favour of the latter would not be in favour of aid to Africa.
 
Its an interesting world.
0 Comments

Life is Turning Into a Winner Take All Society

2/25/2012

0 Comments

 
One of my professors in undergraduate once told me that "there are more positions than geniuses". I think the returns to mediocrity seem to be diminishing and this has some severe implications for the society. It seems more and more of our economic activity is organized around a tournament structure where a small minority receive enormous payoffs and the rest benefit very little. 

Reality televison is the cultural canary in a coal mine that marks this broader employment trend with shows like 'The Apprentice', 'The Amazing Race', 'American Idol', 'Survivor', 'The Bachelor','The Bachelorette','The Biggest Loser' etc...

As recently reported by the NY Times,
"Now, many economists fear that the comfortable Plan B jobs are disappearing. Technology and cheaper goods from overseas have replaced many of the not-especially-creative professions. A tax accountant loses clients to TurboTax; many graphic designers have been replaced by Photoshop; and the small shopkeeper by Home Depot, Walmart or Duane Reade. Though a lottery economy is valuable to various industries, the thought of an entire lottery-based economy, in which a few people win big while the rest are forced to toil in an uncertain and not terribly remunerative dead-end labor pool, is unfair and politically  scary. If large numbers of people believe they have no shot at a better life in the future, they will work less hard and generate fewer new ideas and businesses. The economy, as a whole, will be poorer."    

This is not new, Frank and Cook identified this emerging trend 17 years ago. Robert Shiller advocates redistribution to prevent inequality from increasing.   
0 Comments

Trade update

10/14/2011

1 Comment

 
 
On several of my past posts, I have declared that the US is likely to become more trade protectionist in order to deal with its problems of  long term structural unemployment; whereas it would be better off pursuing a  development agenda as advocated by Jeffrey Sachs. 
  
This week, US policy went completely counter to my prediction, as three long outstanding trade bills were signed with Panama, Columbia, and South Korea.

So have I lost faith in my prediction? No, not all. We are still in the early innings, politically, of the issue of structural unemployment; my own estimate is that the real debate on this issue won’t begin until after the 2012 Presidential election. 

Also, the US politically, like most of us personally, is full of contradictions. Congress is simultaneously trying to pass legislation that would force China to make its currency appreciate so that it terms of trade with the US would worsen.

 Politico had this to say about the new free trade deals:

“Advocates say the deals will result in the export of billions of dollars of U.S. goods and boost hundreds of thousands of American jobs.”

 Really? In the same way free trade with China helped the US manufacturing sector lose 7 million jobs last  decade?

A new study by David Autor, Gordon Hanson, and David Dorn explains the “job creation benefits” of trade with China. 
http://econ-www.mit.edu/files/6613  (right click to download)

 Marginal Revolution summarizes the study:
“The study rated every U.S. county for their manufacturers’ exposure to competition from China, and found that regions most exposed to China tended not only to lose more manufacturing jobs, but also to see overall employment decline. Areas with higher exposure also had larger increases in workers receiving unemployment insurance, food stamps and disability
payments.
 
The authors calculate that the cost to the economy from the increased government payments amounts to one- to two-thirds of the gains from trade with China. In other words, a big portion of the ways trade with China has helped the U.S.—such as by providing inexpensive Chinese goods to consumers—has been wiped out. And that estimate doesn’t include any economic losses experienced by people who lost their jobs.”

The reaility in the US economy is that:
Unemployment for those people with a university degree in the US is 4%

Unemployment for those without a high school education is 16%. 

Ben Bernake has recently weighed in on the issue of structural unemployment:
“Bernanke noted that about 45 percent of the unemployed have been out of work for at least six months.

"This is unheard of," he said in a question-and-answer session after a speech in Cleveland. "This has never happened in the post-war period in the United States. They are losing the skills they had, they are losing their connections, their attachment to the labor force."

He added: "The unemployment situation we have, the job situation, is really a national crisis." Bernanke said the government needs to provide support to help the long-term unemployed retrain for jobs and find work. And he suggested that Congress should take more responsibility.”

Put simply, by signing these trade agreements, congress has put in place policies aimed at providing market access for US corporations allowing them to grow profits and send low skill jobs off shore - while simultaneously providing jobs for the high skilled labour market.

The trade agreements benefit the elites in US society at the expense of the most vulnerable in US society.

Jeffrey Sachs sums it up quite well in the first paragraph of his new book 'The Price of Civilization: Reawakening American Virtue and Prosperity'. 

"At the root of America’s crisis lies a moral crisis: the decline of civic virtue among America’s political and economic elite. A society of markets, laws and elections is not enough if the rich and powerful fail to behave with respect, honesty and compassion towards the rest of society and toward the world. America has developed the world’s most competitive market society but has squandered its civic virtue along the way. Without restoring an ethos of social responsibility there can be no meaningful and sustained recovery. I find myself deeply surprised and unnerved to have to write this book."

 

1 Comment

I guess I am overdue for a Eurozone post

9/30/2011

0 Comments

 
As the drama unfolding in the Eurozone is moving toward its final act, this chapter of European history, which began as a romance, is now morphing  into a Greek Tragedy.  Unfortunately for the global economy there is no “Deus ex machina”
waiting in the wings to swoop down and save the Euro – it will collapse. The  Eurozone is trying to be a little pregnant, either you completely integrate,  form a fiscal union and become “The United States of Europe” or you have to  disband and let countries have their own monetary policy. The former is unimaginable therefore the latter will happen. In April of last year, I argued  that the contagion would spread to Italy, that investors should purchase credit  default swaps (CDS) on Italian debt and that this would be the destabilizing  event that would eventually trigger the Euro’s collapse. Italian bonds just recently came under pressure.  

In the absence of monetary policy, the only way  that Greece, Italy, Ireland, Portugal, or Spain (PIIGS) can become competitive
with Germany is through a period of sustained deflation.  This traps them in a vicious cycle. PIIGS cuts its spending and raises
  taxes which lower aggregate demand; this leads to higher budget deficits which  lead to cuts in spending and higher taxes which lead to lower aggregate demand.  Rinse, wash, and repeat.  Though I  identified this problem a year ago, we can now see that this is what is actually  happening in Greece.  By way of comparison,  Argentina tried to maintain a peg with  the US dollar in the late 90s, experienced deflation that caused social upheaval  and eventually went off the peg and defaulted on its debt. 
 
Greece owes over $500 Billion Euros to French and German Banks. In commercial lending, we used to have a saying, “if  you owe the bank one hundred thousand dollars that’s your problem, if you owe the bank a million dollars that’s the bank problem.” The Greek debt is no longer a problem of the Greeks. It is a problem of the French and German banks, which,  just like the US policy response to their financial crisis in 2008, is being passed down to the French and German taxpayer.  After Greece has implemented the much needed reforms that will allow for economic competiveness, stability and long term viability, the Greek bargaining position will start at “we will refloat the drachma and default on all our debt”.  At that point, Germany, and the rest of the Eurozone will be in a very poor bargaining position.

Argentina only paid its bond holders 40 cents on the dollar. The latest  bailout for Greece represents a 21% haircut so there is still much pain in the pipeline.  And for those of you who might be  inclined to think this type of can kicking can go on forever - don’t. To cover all the bad Eurozone debt some are estimating that Germany would have to issue  debt as high as 133% of GDP.

The Eurozone was never built to last, and I warned my students in my International Macroeconomics classes, since 2002, that it would not likely survive due to differences in the various economies and their inabilility to make adjustments through monetary policy.
 
I was not the only one thinking this way.

So did Milton Freidman at a Bank of Canada conference in 2000 :
Milton Friedman:…I think the euro is in its honeymoon phase. I hope it succeeds, but I have very low expectations for it. I think that differences are going to  accumulate among the various countries and that non-synchronous shocks are going  to affect them. Right now, Ireland is a very different state; it needs a very different monetary policy from that of Spain or Italy. On purely theoretical  grounds, it’s hard to believe that it’s going to be a stable system for a long time.


A curiosity of all this is that although the Eurozone was never an optimal currency zone, Robert Mundell, who won a nobel prize in part for this theory, has beeen a cheerleader from the Euro's inception.

More recently Mundell was quoted as saying:
 
"The euro is too strong. A weaker euro is the best news you could have for  governments (in trouble)."


"The ECB should follow an easier policy. Of course they have a strict rule to safeguard against inflation but that is not correct. I have never believed that  central banks should have rigid inflation targeting. That is not a good thing to  stabilize. There is nothing in economic theory to back this."


He added it is folly to tighten monetary policy into a "deflationary" oil  spike, (as the ECB did in 2008 and has just done again). "That is exactly the  wrong thing to do".

While it is true that the ECB could of been following a looser  policy, the value of the Euro is basically based on Germany's productivity  which means that its equilibrium value, short of a massive inflationary policy by the ECB, will be too high for the competitiveness of the PIIGS. Only prolonged  deflation, currently being prevented by the bailouts in the case of Greece, can  bring these countries into international competitiveness.
 

What's more, these countries have to deal with the fact that the low wage manufacturing jobs that went to China and other developing countries and are not coming back. Germany is positioned in the high value added manufacturing sector and it will not be easy for these countries to carve out a competitive  niche without some sort of sustained program of economic development, akin to that which Jeffrey Sachs is advocating for the United Sates. Given these realities, it will simply be easier to dissolve the Eurozone, float your own currency, and impose trade sanctions to establish jobs for the lower skilled workers.
0 Comments

    Author

    Karl Pinno

    Categories

    All
    60 Minutes
    Abnormal Returns
    Academic Publishing
    Advice For Econ Students
    Age
    Aid
    Algo Trading
    Aluminum
    Argentina
    Assortive Matching
    Austerity
    Bank Of England
    Behavioural Economics
    Bio Weapons
    Bis
    Bloomberg
    Bonds
    Bono
    Book Of Mormon
    Brain
    Brazil
    Brics
    Bridgewater Associates
    Buffet
    Calgary
    Canada
    Capital Flight
    Carola Binder
    Cds
    Central Banks
    Chainmail Bikinis
    Chanos
    Child Rearing
    China
    Chris Martenson
    Christmas Wishlist
    Climate Change
    College Humor
    Commercial Banks
    Commodities
    Community
    Computer Programming
    Confirmation Bias
    Conservatism
    Conservative
    Constructive Ambiquity
    Consumer Confidence
    Copper
    Corporate Lending
    Counterparty Risk
    Creativity
    Credit
    Culture
    Cwb
    David Einhorn
    David Rosenberg
    Debate
    Debt Crisis
    Deflation
    Demographics
    Depression
    Development
    Dragons
    Dr. Ed's Blog
    Econ Blogs
    Economics
    Ecri
    Education
    Electricity
    Eurasia Group
    Eurozone
    Excercise
    Externalities
    Falkenblog
    Ferguson
    Fertility
    Filtering
    Financial Crisis 2008
    Financial Engineering
    Financial Reform
    Financial Repression
    Financial Research
    Fiscal Policy
    Fiscal Stimulus
    Fisher
    Fixed Income
    Flood
    Food Prices
    Frank And Cook
    Fraud
    Freidman
    Ft
    Game Theory
    Gender
    Generalist
    George Soros
    Get Smart
    Giffen Good
    Global Banking
    Global Economy
    Gmo
    Godfather
    Gold
    Goldman Sachs
    Great Careers
    Greece
    Greenlight Capital
    Happiness
    Hayman Capital Management Lp
    Hbo
    Health
    Hedge Funds
    Homosexuality
    Housing Market
    Hubbard
    Hugh Hendry
    Hussman
    Ian Bremmer
    Imf
    Inception
    Income Smoothing
    India
    Inequality
    Inflation
    Inflationary Expectations
    Inside Job
    Interest Rates
    Interfluidity
    Intuition
    Inventories
    Iran
    Iraq
    Italy
    Janusian Thinking
    Japan
    Jordan Peterson
    Jp Morgan
    Judgement
    Kalecki Equation
    Krugman
    Kyle Bass
    Larry Smith
    Larry Summers
    Lehman Brothers
    Levitt
    Liberal
    Lonely Island
    Luck
    Macro
    Macro Intro
    Macro Predictions
    Management Consulting
    Marginal Revolution
    Market Design
    Market Monetarism
    Marx
    Matt Taibbi
    Mercantilism
    Michael Portillo
    Milton Friedman
    Mircea Eliade
    Mish
    Mishkin
    Monetary Policy
    Monetary Stimulus
    Multipliers
    Mundell
    Music
    Nanex
    Nfl
    Noahpinion
    Nobel Price In Economics
    Oil Price Volatility
    Oil Production
    Omitted Variable Bias
    Optimism Bias
    Overcomingbias
    Palantir
    Pettis
    Phillips Curve
    Placebo
    Podcasts
    Poker
    Poland
    Politico
    Politics
    Populism
    Portfolio Management
    Positivism
    Prisoner's Dilemma
    Productivity
    Psychology
    Publishing
    Quality
    Quantitative Easing
    Race
    Rand Paul
    Ray Dalio
    Rbc Theory
    Real Interest Rates
    Reality Tv
    Recession
    Redistributionist Reform
    Regulators
    Regulatory Capture
    Remembrance Day
    Research
    Richard Wilkinson
    Riots
    Risk
    Risk Taking
    Robots
    Roubini
    Russia
    Ryan
    Sachs
    Salt
    Saudi Arabia
    Sec
    Seth Klarman
    Shadowbanking
    Shiller
    Signaling
    Smes
    Snap
    Social Policy
    Social Unrest
    Society
    Sorkin
    Soros
    S&P
    Spain
    Specialization
    Speculation
    State Sponsored Terrorism
    Status
    Steve Jobs
    Steven Keen
    Stress
    Structural Unemployment
    Structure Finance
    Sugar
    Suicide
    Svars
    Systemic Risk
    Tax
    Taylor Rule
    Technology
    Ted
    Television
    The Clash
    The Economist
    The Wire
    Thinking
    Thoureau
    Trade
    Trilemma
    Turkey
    Tyler Cowen
    U2
    Unemployment
    Us 2012 Election
    Us Economy
    Us Foreign Policy
    Velocity
    Volatility
    Welfare
    Williams
    Words
    Work
    Writing
    Zerohedge
    Zig Ziglar

    Archives

    November 2017
    October 2017
    March 2017
    January 2017
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    February 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012
    June 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012
    January 2012
    December 2011
    November 2011
    October 2011
    September 2011
    August 2011

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.